한국어

네트워킹

온누리070 플레이스토어 다운로드
    acrobits softphone
     온누리 070 카카오 프러스 친구추가온누리 070 카카오 프러스 친구추가친추
     카카오톡 채팅 상담 카카오톡 채팅 상담카톡
    
     라인상담
     라인으로 공유

     페북공유

   ◎위챗 : speedseoul


  
     PAYPAL
     
     PRICE
     

pixel.gif

    before pay call 0088 from app


Which is better, GCC or Clang?


  • GCC supports languages that clang does not aim to, such as Java, Ada, FORTRAN, Go, etc.
  • GCC supports more targets than LLVM.
  • GCC supports many language extensions, some of which are not implemented by Clang. For instance, in C mode, GCC supports nested functions and has an extension allowing VLAs in structs.

Pro's of clang vs GCC:

  • The Clang ASTs and design are intended to be easily understandableby anyone who is familiar with the languages involved and who has a basic understanding of how a compiler works. GCC has a very old codebase which presents a steep learning curve to new developers.
  • Clang is designed as an API from its inception, allowing it to be reused by source analysis tools, refactoring, IDEs (etc) as well as for code generation. GCC is built as a monolithic static compiler, which makes it extremely difficult to use as an API and integrate into other tools. Further, its historic design and current policy makes it difficult to decouple the front-end from the rest of the compiler.
  • Various GCC design decisions make it very difficult to reuse: its build system is difficult to modify, you can't link multiple targets into one binary, you can't link multiple front-ends into one binary, it uses a custom garbage collector, uses global variables extensively, is not reentrant or multi-threadable, etc. Clang has none of these problems.
  • Clang does not implicitly simplify code as it parses it like GCC does. Doing so causes many problems for source analysis tools: as one simple example, if you write "x-x" in your source code, the GCC AST will contain "0", with no mention of 'x'. This is extremely bad for a refactoring tool that wants to rename 'x'.
  • Clang can serialize its AST out to disk and read it back into another program, which is useful for whole program analysis. GCC does not have this. GCC's PCH mechanism (which is just a dump of the compiler memory image) is related, but is architecturally only able to read the dump back into the exact same executable as the one that produced it (it is not a structured format).
  • Clang is much faster and uses far less memory than GCC.
  • Clang has been designed from the start to provide extremely clear and concise diagnostics (error and warning messages), and includes support for expressive diagnostics. Modern versions of GCC have made significant advances in this area, incorporating various Clang features such as preserving typedefs in diagnostics and showing macro expansions, but GCC is still catching up.
  • GCC is licensed under the GPL license. clang uses a BSD license,which allows it to be embedded in software that is not GPL-licensed.
  • Clang inherits a number of features from its use of LLVM as a backend, including support for a bytecode representation for intermediate code, pluggable optimizers, link-time optimization support, Just-In-Time compilation, ability to link in multiple code generators, etc.
  • Clang's support for C++ is more compliant than GCC's in many ways.
  • Clang supports many language extensions, some of which are not implemented by GCC. For instance, Clang provides attributes for checking thread safety and extended vector types.

So, As a final thought, I think clang is better. Clang is backed by Google, Apple and Microsoft too. Latest version of clang is 5.0 and Clang AST is more advanced used by professional and Clang tooling is cool also. For example, Clang-format works great with vim and emacs. Clang error message and warnings is more robust than GCC. Clang has thread sanitizer, ASAN(Address sanitizer), MSAN and finally LLVM(low level virtual machine) compiler infrastructure project is really cool.

Barry Rountree

If you’re doing compiler research, LLVM/Clang is much, much easier to modify as plugins were part of the original architecture.

If you’re wanting faster binaries, there’s no substitute for trying them both and measuring the results.

Anton Carver

I assume you mean G++ (not GCC which is either the C compiler or the whole compiler system).

G++ still tends to generate slightly faster code for most cases. Clang tends to be much stricter about conformance to the standard (though G++ seems to be getting better). Clang / LLVM is generally more tool friendly, if you are interested in manipulating C++ code in a tool. GCC is GPL and Clang is BSD License.

There isn’t much in it really, they are both pretty good

조회 수 :
63020
등록일 :
2018.06.13
14:25:20 (*.160.88.18)
엮인글 :
http://www.webs.co.kr/index.php?document_srl=3316316&act=trackback&key=7d8
게시글 주소 :
http://www.webs.co.kr/index.php?document_srl=3316316
List of Articles
번호 제목 글쓴이 조회 수sort 추천 수 날짜
63 리눅스 tar 압축 백업복원시 소유자 문제해결 admin 37093   2011-12-16
 
62 스트리밍서버 / 윈도우서버 admin 37528   2011-12-16
 
61 ftp 파일전송 여러파일을 한번에 통째로 전송 admin 37618   2011-12-16
 
60 암호 없이 SSH 접속하기 admin 37931   2013-09-05
 
59 scp 명령어를 이용한 파일 복사 및 전송 admin 37986   2014-10-29
 
58 seagate HD 시게이트 하드 디스크 A/S 에이에스 기간 조회 및 받는 3가지 방법 admin 38089   2013-12-09
 
57 리눅스 네트워크 설정 멸령어 Linux admin 38140   2013-04-08
 
56 SSH Without Authentication Using Key Files (CentOS 5.6) admin 38415   2013-11-22
 
55 리눅스에서 자바(JDK) 설치하기 admin 38448   2013-04-08
 
54 Debian CD DVD 다운로드 링크 헤메지말고 바로 다운로드하지요 admin 38953   2012-08-18
 
53 linux 파티션 디렉토리 용량 확인방법 전체 폴더 크기 사이즈 admin 40599   2012-01-05
 
52 모든 CPU 벤치마크 수치 admin 40800   2011-12-16
 
51 scp, ssh, rsync등을 사용할때에 SSH 비밀번호 묻는것 피하기 admin 41066   2012-04-15
 
50 리눅스 네트워크 설정 LINUX admin 41588   2011-12-19
 
49 kali linux 해킹 hacking attack DDOS etc tools admin 41595   2015-06-24
 
48 How to install Java on linux with no Internet connectivity (using local repository) admin 42186   2017-10-01
 
47 [Linux/SSL] 리눅스 서버에 Apache 2 설치 및 SSL 설정하기(mod_ssl, openssl) admin 42362   2012-04-15
 
46 How to disable IPv6 in Debian , 리눅스 아이피설정 admin 44909   2011-12-16
 
45 How to disable IPv6 in Debian Lenny and Squeeze admin 45170   2011-12-29
 
44 apt-get install linux-image-2.6.26-2-686-bigmem admin 47049   2015-06-27
 
43 FREE RADIUS 활용및 응용 admin 47066   2013-02-23
 
42 윈도우 2003 작업 스케줄러 설정 admin 47229   2011-12-16
 
41 How To Install Java with Apt-Get on Ubuntu 16.04 oracle java admin 47306   2017-10-13
 
» Which is better, GCC or Clang? admin 63020   2018-06-13
Which is better, GCC or Clang? GCC supports languages that clang does not aim to, such as Java, Ada, FORTRAN, Go, etc. GCC supports more targets than LLVM. GCC supports many language extensions, some ...  
39 How to install a Debian 9 (Stretch) Minimal Server 데비안 9 설치 admin 63581   2018-06-13
 
38 useradd Command 리눅스 admin 63692   2017-12-15
 
37 OpenVPN - Getting started How-To admin 67400   2017-09-20
 
36 리눅스 부팅시 시작시 프로그램 명령어 실행하기 (Linux Init script) admin 73162   2017-08-30
 
35 Linux 시스템 백업과 복원 admin 74365   2013-04-04
 
34 한국인/국내기업은 얼마나 Linux Kernel에 기여할까? admin 76948   2012-04-29